Alternatives to Solubol

by Jade Shutes

Essential Oil Solubilizers: Creating Effective Water-Based Sprays

Creating aromatic room sprays, linen sprays, and shower spa mists with essential oils presents a common challenge: water and oil don’t naturally mix. Without proper solubilization, essential oils will separate and float to the top of water-based formulations, resulting in uneven distribution, potential irritation when concentrated oil contacts skin, and inconsistent fragrance experience. Solubilizers are specialized ingredients that help essential oils disperse evenly throughout water-based solutions, creating stable and effective aromatic sprays for your home and personal care.

What is a Solubilizer?

A solubilizer is an ingredient that helps disperse oils into water by forming micelles (tiny droplets) that encapsulate the oil molecules, allowing them to distribute evenly throughout the water base. This creates a clear, stable solution without the need for shaking before use.

Common Solubilizer for Essential Oils

Solubol (Traditional Standard)

Composition: Vegetal glycerin, water, soy lecithin, natural extract of coconut, trisodium citrate, ascorbic acid, citric acid, vitamin E acetate, sunflower oil, and rosemary extract

Usage Rate: 4:1 ratio (4 parts Solubol to 1 part essential oil), then diluted at least 20 times with water

Cost:

    • 1 fl oz: $17.00
    • 4 fl oz: $39.00

5 Cost Effective Alternatives to Solubol include:

    • PlantaSol CCG
    • Sunflower Solubilizer
    • Olive Solubilizer
    • Caprol Micro Express
    • PlantaMulse Liquid

Cost Analysis Based on Usage Rates

For this analysis, let’s calculate the cost to solubilize 5ml (approximately 100 drops) of essential oil, which would be enough for several batches of room spray:

Solubol

    • Usage ratio: 4:1 (4 parts Solubol to 1 part essential oil)
    • Amount needed for 5ml essential oil: 20ml (0.68 oz)
    • Cost using 1 oz size ($17.00/oz): $17.00 × 0.68 oz = $11.56 per 5ml of essential oil
    • Cost using 4 oz size ($9.75/oz): $9.75 × 0.68 oz = $6.63 per 5ml of essential oil

Caprol Micro Express (CME)

    • Usage rate: 10-15% in final formulation
    • For a typical 100ml spray with 5ml essential oil, you would need: 10-15ml CME
    • Using the higher end (15ml = 0.51 oz): $1.99 × 0.51 oz = $1.01 per 5ml of essential oil
    • Using bulk pricing ($1.15/oz): $1.15 × 0.51 oz = $0.59 per 5ml of essential oil

PlantaSol CCG

    • Starting ratio: 1:1 with essential oil, can range up to 10%
    • Amount needed for 5ml essential oil (at 1:1 ratio): 5ml (0.17 oz)
    • Cost: $2.63 × 0.17 oz = $0.45 per 5ml of essential oil
    • At maximum recommended usage (10% in a 100ml spray): 10ml (0.34 oz)
    • Cost at maximum usage: $2.63 × 0.34 oz = $0.89 per 5ml of essential oil

Sunflower Solubilizer

    • Usage rate: 0.5-6% in final formulation
    • For a 100ml spray with 5ml essential oil, you would need: 0.5-6ml
    • Using the higher end (6ml = 0.20 oz): $2.30 × 0.20 oz = $0.46 per 5ml of essential oil

Olive Solubilizer

    • Usage rate: 0.5-6% in final formulation
    • For a 100ml spray with 5ml essential oil, you would need: 0.5-6ml
    • Using the higher end (6ml = 0.20 oz): $2.49 × 0.20 oz = $0.50 per 5ml of essential oil

Comparative Cost Ranking (Per 5ml of Essential Oil)

    1. PlantaSol CCG (1:1 ratio): $0.45
    2. Sunflower Solubilizer: $0.46
    3. Olive Solubilizer: $0.50
    4. Caprol Micro Express (bulk pricing): $0.59
    5. Caprol Micro Express (small quantity): $1.01
    6. PlantaSol CCG (at maximum 10% usage): $0.89
    7. Solubol (4 oz size): $6.63
    8. Solubol (1 oz size): $11.56

As you can see, when accounting for usage rates, Solubol is significantly more expensive than the alternatives – costing between 13-25 times more than the most economical option (PlantaSol at a 1:1 ratio).

Formulation Guidelines for Home and Body Sprays

Basic Room and Linen Spray Formula (100ml)

Ingredients:

    • Distilled water: 95-98 ml
    • Essential oil blend: 15-30 drops (approximately 0.75-1.5 ml)
    • Solubilizer: Varies by product (see below)
    • Optional: Preservative as desired

Solubilizer Amounts for 100ml Spray:

    • Solubol: 3-6 ml (4:1 ratio with essential oil)
    • Caprol Micro Express: 10-15 ml
    • PlantaSol CCG: 1-10 ml (start with 1:1 ratio)
    • Sunflower or Olive Solubilizer: 0.5-6 ml

Shower Spa Mist Formula (100ml)

Ingredients:

    • Distilled water: 92-95 ml
    • Essential oil blend: 20-40 drops (approximately 1-2 ml)
    • Solubilizer: Varies by product (slightly higher than room sprays)
    • Optional: 1-2 ml vegetable glycerin (helps scent linger in steamy environment)
    • Preservative: As desired

Solubilizer Amounts for 100ml Shower Mist:

    • Caprol Micro Express: 12-18 ml
    • PlantaSol CCG: 1-12 ml (may need higher ratio in steam)
    • Sunflower or Olive Solubilizer: 1-8 ml

Essential Oil Blend Suggestions

Relaxing Room/Linen Spray:

    • 8 drops Lavender
    • 5 drops Sweet Orange
    • 2 drops Chamomile

Energizing Room Spray:

    • 10 drops Lemon
    • 5 drops Rosemary
    • 3 drops Peppermint

Purifying Room Spray:

    • 7 drops Tea Tree
    • 7 drops Lemon
    • 3 drops Eucalyptus

Shower Spa Blend – Morning Wake-Up:

    • 12 drops Grapefruit
    • 8 drops Spearmint
    • 5 drops Eucalyptus

Shower Spa Blend – Evening Relaxation:

    • 10 drops Lavender
    • 8 drops Bergamot
    • 5 drops Ylang Ylang

When comparing the actual cost to solubilize the same amount of essential oil for your room, linen, and shower sprays, PlantaSol CCG emerges as the most cost-effective option at just $0.45 per 5ml of essential oil, compared to $11.56 for Solubol (1 oz size) – representing a savings of over 96%.

Caprol Micro Express offers exceptional clarity for showcase room sprays where appearance matters.

For home crafters and professional formulators, these alternatives offer:

    1. Substantial cost savings on frequently used spray products
    2. The ability to create more sprays with the same budget
    3. Options tailored to different spray applications
    4. Better performance in specific environments (shower steam, fabric application)